As the dust settles on the 2026 midterm elections, a stark disconnect has emerged between the relentless religious messaging of political campaigns and the day-to-day priorities of young voters.
While candidates across the political spectrum emphasized faith-based values throughout the election cycle, many young constituents—focused on inflation, housing affordability, and broader economic concerns—felt alienated by the heavy campaign spending allocated to religious and cultural grievances.
For students at American University, the national debate over religion in politics is increasingly personal; reflecting a tension between individual faith and political strategy.
Lucy-Joy, or LJ, Yoon, sophomore studying in the Baker’s School of Education and a member of AU Catholics, said that we’re past the world where religion is a private matter, and not a politician’s talking point.
“There is no world where religion doesn’t play a role in politics, and not just Christianity in general, but I do think it has gone too far,” said Yoon.
Yoon’s feelings are echoed across campus, particularly as political rhetoric clashes with the country’s shifting demographics.
Despite 17% of U.S. adults saying that the government should declare Christianity the nation’s official religion, an overwhelming majority (61% of U.S. adults) say that religion is losing influence in American life according to a survey regarding partisans perspectives on the nation’s religiosity conducted by Pew Research Center in May 2026.
Christian imagery and messaging have remained prominent in the Trump administration. In April 2026, President Donald Trump posted an artificially generated image of him depicted as Jesus Christ, with an American flag waving behind him, on Truth Social.
In 2025, 41% of the population identified as White Christians, while those who practiced Judaism, Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism made up 6% of the population according to the Public Religion Research Institute, a lab dedicated to exploring the intersections between religion, culture and public policy.
As the most secular generation in U.S. history, these young voters are increasingly alienated by rhetoric that merges church and state.
Roughly 34% of Gen Z adults now identify as religiously unaffiliated, according to a demographic poll describing religious affiliations and perceptions of morality from Pew Center Center in Jan. 2024.
“I think it would be best to not bring religion into it as much as possible,” said LJ Yoon, “but also acknowledge that it’s not possible for it to completely be erased.”
Religion became a contentious issue in Michigan’s Senate race. Democratic Senator, Abdul El-Sayed, who is Muslim, faced a barrage of Islamophobic attacks from Republican candidate Mike Rogers.
Michigan has one of the largest concentrations of Arab American and Muslim voters in the country according to a 2026 growth trends report by the Arab American Institute.
In a political ad released on Oct. 1, Rogers baselessly alleged that El-Sayed was a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, and a threat to national security—accusations El-Sayed firmly denied.
These attacks reflect a broader nationwide surge in anti-Muslim sentiment. In its 2025 Civil Rights Report, the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) revealed that Islamphobia and anti-Muslim discrimination complaints had reached an all-time high across the United States.
Matt Luke, a Michigan voter and El-Sayed campaign volunteer, said the ad was a dishonorable attempt to soil El-Sayed’s reputation and promise of a progressive future.
“The ads against him are deplorable,” said Luke, “They’re trying to paint him as something that he absolutely isn’t.
According to the voter mobilization organization Emgage, there are over 1,500,000 registered Muslim voters that showed up to the polls for the 2020 election—a highly organized demographic that has historically provided the margin of victory in tight, statewide Michigan races.
Maryam Q, a Catholic student at Wayne University, saw the attacks as a hypocritical use of faith. Her support for El-Sayed comes from the fact that his religious faith is an aspect of his identity, not the crux of his campaign.
“Even though they are trying to weaponize his faith and dehumanize him, I think he’s one of the only ones who follows our faith more than other candidates,” Q said.
Beyond the campaign trail, the push to elevate specific religious ideologies has extended into government policy. While President Donald Trump has used religious imagery to rally voters, actions within the Pentagon represent a structural shift.
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth recently announced the establishment of an Office of Religious Affairs on Sept. 30, a move that military chaplains fear will promote a monolithic representation of faith. This followed a decision from the Department of Defense to drastically reduce its list of acknowledged religions from 211 down to 30— over 70% of which are Christian denominations.
Many critiqued how such actions lacked inclusivity and potentially could reinforce ideological tolerance.
Even for young voters who are deeply religious, current political strategies fall short.
As the political landscape pivots to focus on the 2028 presidential election, the continued reliance on faith-based platforms poses a unique risk for campaigns targeting younger demographics.
“I think everyone should have the freedom to do whatever they want, and we shouldn’t be forcing people to practice Christianity if they don’t want to,” said Yoon, “What are you gonna do? You can’t force someone to be religious.”
Adaobi (Myles) Nwatu, Vanessa Brum, and Jessica Ackerman contributed to this report.





Add comment