The Wash
From Left: Majority Whip nominee Rep. Pete Aguilar, D-CA, and Majority Leader nominee Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y. at a press conference today announcing the nominations. The Wash/Wraith Saucier

Democrats nominate Jeffries, but hurdles ahead

Democrats nominated Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., to be the next Speaker of the House. But left-wing members and protestors say Jeffries hasn’t proven that his leadership will bring the change Americans voted for.

The Democratic Caucus today selected Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., as the party’s nominee for Speaker of the House in a closed-door vote, putting him easily on track to make history as the nation’s first Black Speaker. 

Jim Clyburn spoke to the press after today’s vote. The Wash/Deona Easterson

Cheers could be heard from outside the meeting room as the vote was finalized. Jeffries’ nomination signals a historic shift towards diversity in the House. 

Rep. Jim Clyburn, D-S.C., said he felt like his Civil Rights-era efforts are yielding results.

“I spent several times in several jails fighting for this, and it means all the anxieties I had back then seem to be paying off,” said Clyburn, who was arrested in the 1960s for his participation in Civil Rights movement. He recounted the 251-11 vote in his remarks.

Clyburn said he devoted his time on the midterm election campaign trail to supporting Black candidates, but was surprised by the overwhelming amount of support that Black candidates received.

A historically diverse Congress

Jeffries’ nomination shows where the center of gravity currently stands for the Democratic Party, said Steven Taylor, professor of government emeritus at American University. 

Black voters have maintained allegiance to the Democratic Party even in times when it was abandoned by white people, Taylor said, so “it was only a matter of time before they assumed the leadership of the party.”

Jeffries struck the same note. 

“The 120th Congress is going to be the most diverse in America’s history, and we know what brings people together are the challenges that Americans of every walk of life are experiencing,” Jeffries said in a press conference following his nomination. 

Having now passed the closed-door vote for Speaker nominee, Jeffries will need to maintain the caucus’s favor to formalize his appointment in January, when the newly elected Congress is sworn in.

Democrats also nominated Rep. Katherine Clark, D-MA, as the first female House majority leader and Rep. Pete Aguilar, D-CA, the first Latino House majority whip.

“Fittingly, the 120th Congress will boast a record shattering 120 Democratic congresswomen,” said Clark.

A low possibility to flip

Outgoing Rep. Thomas Massie, R-KY, noted it would be a “steep lift” for the party’s formal vote in 2027 to stop Jeffries from becoming Speaker, but it is still possible. 

“The real fight isn’t until January,” said Massie.

To maintain the party favor required to secure his appointment, Jeffries needs to stay personable with his caucus, said Taylor.

Jeffries today said the House Democrats would push for affordable groceries, gas, housing, and healthcare. But Massie said that’s not enough.

“Look, we lost the majority over the Iran war and I offered impeachment of Hegseth, eight articles and no other Republican voted for that. So I’m not sure that my colleagues in my conference got the message,” Massie said.

“The question is did the Democrats get the message?” Massie said. “Will Speaker Jeffries defund the war in the next spending bill?”

Detractors call for concrete action

While Jeffries faced no significant challengers ahead of the closed-door vote, he received pushback from some party members and members of the public who want Jeffries to take firmer action against the Trump administration.

Signs read "stability of citizenship helps all works" and "stop reporting moms, dads, & kids."
“The message is clear. A pathway to citizenship, reign in ICE, and also ensure that costs go down so our families can thrive,” said Diana Robinson with Make the Road Action Pennsylvania. The Wash/Wraith Saucier

Outside the Capitol, a group of protesters gathered to pressure Democratic legislators to take action against the current administration’s immigration policies. 

“To our newly elected officials, citizens, communities like ours, we organize, we mobilize, we canvas, we voted. We expect you to deliver. Come January 2027, we expect immediate action within your first 100 hours, within your first 100 days,” said Mildred Dennis Taylor, an activist with CASA in Action Georgia whose husband was detained by ICE for a year, as reported by the Guardian.

Her sentiment was echoed by seven incoming progressive representatives, who said in a joint statement that Jeffries had not committed to taking substantial action against Israel and ICE, in a shared post to Instagram.

The seven representatives voted against Jeffries in the caucus meeting, a decision that was met with criticism from Rep. Sean Casten, D-IL, who said it was a “disruptive” and “symbolic” gesture by progressives. 

But Jeffries remained unconcerned by lost votes from party members. 

“The results of today’s election speak for themselves,” he said. 

Because he won by substantial numbers, Jeffries has a “luxury of the margins,” making his election as Speaker close to concrete, said Tom Moore, a senior fellow at the Center For American Progress, a progressive think tank.

“He can let a lot of people go at any given vote and still win,” Moore added. 

Regardless of the Jan. 3 formal election, Jeffries’ nomination marks a significant milestone for diversity in the House. 

Clyburn reflected on his friendship with the late Civil Rights activist and former representative John Lewis in an address to the press following Jeffries’ historic nomination.  

Clyburn said he and Lewis had a long history, and they had spent many days on the floor together talking about the contrast between their hope for progress in the American government and the reality of what it was. 

“I know what John would be feeling now — he would be over in the corner somewhere, silently weeping.” Clyburn said. “I wish I had a corner to go in today.” 

Nia Ames

Nia Ames is a graduate student pursuing a Master's in Journalism and Public Affairs at American University. She previously studied Politics, Philosophy, and Ethics at York St John University.

Deona Easterson

Deona Easterson is a journalist and graduate student in the Journalism and Public Affairs program at American University. She reports on a range of topics, from community news in the NoMa, H-Street, and Union Market communities to national policy in Congress and the Supreme Court. Her undergraduate studies were in sociology and women/gender studies, informing her interest in social forces and institutions shaping the public.

Jacob Saucier

Jacob "Wraith" Saucier (any/all) is a Journalism and Public Affairs Master's student at American University and an aspiring photo and investigative journalist. Saucier is currently reporting on the MidCity D.C. community and other political affairs.

js2958a@american.edu

Add comment

Follow us

Don't be shy, get in touch. We love meeting interesting people and making new friends.

Most popular

Most discussed